South Setauket Homes for Sale

Welcome to South Setauket, a charming hamlet nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. With its picturesque landscapes and vibrant community spirit, South Setauket offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and easy access to the bustling life of Long Island. This delightful area is renowned for its rich history, scenic parks, and proximity to stunning waterfronts, making it an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

South Setauket boasts an array of beautifully maintained homes for sale, each reflecting the character and charm of this quaint community. From charming colonial homes to modern designs, the real estate options here cater to a variety of tastes and lifestyles. Many properties feature spacious yards, perfect for outdoor gatherings and play, while others offer stunning views of the surrounding nature. Whether you’re looking for a cozy starter home or a luxurious retreat, South Setauket has something to suit every need.

Living in South Setauket means enjoying a strong sense of community, with local events and activities that bring residents together. The area is served by highly-rated schools, making it a great choice for families. Additionally, you’ll find a variety of shopping, dining, and recreational options just a short drive away, ensuring that everything you need is within reach.

Explore the homes for sale in South Setauket today and discover the perfect place to call home in this inviting and vibrant community. Embrace the lifestyle you've always dreamed of in this beautiful corner of Long Island!

Newest South Setauket Homes for Sale

$589,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1029179 MLS

Welcome to 14 Antler Lane, a beautifully updated 2/3 bed ranch tucked away on a peaceful street in the highly sought-after Three Village School District! Set on a spacious .36-acre property, this move-in ready home has been thoughtfully renovated over the past few years, allowing you to simply unpack and enjoy. The heart of the home is the stunning eat-in kitchen, featuring quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, gas cooking, abundant cabinetry, a pantry, and a large picture window that fills the space with natural light. The inviting living room offers crown molding and a beautiful bay window. The large primary bedroom has ample closet space, recessed lighting, and crown molding. A full basement provides endless possibilities for storage and additional living space! Step outside to your expansive wraparound deck overlooking the fully fenced backyard with new PVC fencing, two storage sheds, and plenty of room to enjoy outdoor living. Additional highlights include a one-car garage with a new garage door, 8-zone in-ground sprinklers, central air conditioning, newer windows, siding and gutters, updated 200-amp electrical, a hot water heater less than a year old, gas heat, and a new dryer. From the extensive updates to the quiet neighborhood and exceptional location, 14 Antler Lane is the perfect opportunity to enjoy comfortable, low-maintenance living in one of South Setauket's most desirable communities!

14 Antler Lane, South Setauket

$845,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1026188 MLS

Featuring the former Spring Briar Model Home, this stunning 3,300-square-foot residence offers 5 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, soaring ceilings, spacious rooms, and beautiful hardwood floors. Designed for both comfortable living and entertaining, the home features an inviting family room with a cozy fireplace that flows seamlessly into the well-appointed kitchen, complete with rich wood cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless-steel appliances. A true highlight is the impressive 600-square-foot bonus room, offering exceptional flexibility. Whether you envision a home office, professional workspace, fitness studio, media room, playroom, or guest retreat, this versatile space can easily accommodate your needs. Additional amenities include central air conditioning, central vacuum, underground utilities, and sewers, providing both comfort and efficiency. The expansive parking area offers outstanding convenience and may be ideal for clients or visitors, making this property an excellent option for a home-based business or professional office (subject to local zoning approval). Perfectly situated near major highways, shopping, restaurants, museums, and Stony Brook University and Hospital, this exceptional home combines generous living space, versatility, and endless potential. Located within the highly acclaimed Three Village School District, this is a rare opportunity to own a home that truly offers it all.

65 Betty Ann Drive, South Setauket

$799,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1021893 MLS

Large Hi-Ranch with Flexible Living Spaces on a Quiet Dead End Street. Offers a versatile layout designed for today's lifestyle. The main living area features an eat-in kitchen with butcher block countertops and stainless-steel appliances, a formal living room, three bedrooms, and a full bathroom. The lower-level area includes a separate den/family room and a bedroom or office for flexible use, along with a half bath, laundry area, private entrance with 2nd kitchen. House has lots of potential. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, a major university, and three hospitals. This home combines comfort, flexibility, and a prime location.

10 Arrowhead Court, South Setauket

$1,288,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1016509 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home located on a quiet horseshoe street in the desirable Pondfield Crossing neighborhood. Designed for comfortable living and effortless entertaining, the spacious main living area features hardwood floors and a cozy gas fireplace, complemented by additional family room space and a dining room conveniently located just off the kitchen. The updated kitchen (2023) boasts quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances, while the primary bath was renovated in 2024 and features radiant heated flooring. The walk-out lower level offers exceptional versatility with separate living quarters, an additional full bath, a movie theater, wine room, and ample storage with custom barn door. Step outside to your own private retreat featuring a Trex deck with outdoor kitchen, perfect for entertaining, a stunning pool with waterfall, half-court basketball court, and a storage shed. This exceptional home offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and recreation in one of the area's most sought-after neighborhoods.

20 Hancock Court, South Setauket

$729,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 996694 MLS

Welcome home to this spacious Colonial on a quiet and safe street in the top-rated Three Village School District. Featuring a fully permitted two-story extension, this home offers an incredibly versatile floor plan with multi-functional spaces.The main floor greets you with a high-ceiling living room, dining room, and bright kitchen. The generous layout includes a cozy den (or 5th bedroom), a dedicated hobby/craft area, and a sunroom perfect for year-round relaxation. Upstairs, the primary suite includes a full bath and a connected, separate office or nursery. Three additional bedrooms share the second floor. A major hidden bonus: gorgeous hardwood floors sit under the carpeting on both the stairs and the entire upper level. Outside, enjoy a beautifully paved patio made for entertaining, plus a convenient 1-car garage. Bring your personal touch to a legally expanded home with incredible bones and an excellent location! Stony Brook University is fewer than 10 minutes by car and the closest train is only 4 miles away. This home already has low taxes, but a 10-minute online grievance will likely bring the taxes to approximately $10,800! New Cesspools (2020) and new 40 yr. roof (2012)

2 Cub Road, South Setauket

$674,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1007565 MLS

Welcome to South Setauket! Nestled on a quiet corner parcel, this spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bath SPRAWLING RANCH offers comfortable living on ONE LEVEL with a nice sized basement ready to be finished. At just about 2,000 square feet of living space (without the basement), the home provides a functional layout with generous room sizes, abundant natural light, and ample space for both everyday living and entertaining. The living area is extra large, providing the perfect opportunity to expand and open the kitchen to create the space of your dreams! The bedrooms are all generously sized and feature new carpeting, while the primary suite includes its own full bathroom. There is a one-car attached garage and rear mudroom where the laundry is conveniently located—making true one-level living possible. The garage also features a stairway to the attic, providing easy access to additional storage space. Upgrades include natural gas heating, Anderson windows, a paved driveway with patio pavers and walkway, and an in-ground sprinkler system in both the front and back yards. Ideally located near Stony Brook University, Stony Brook University Hospital, Mather Hospital, St. Charles Hospital, Stony Brook Research Labs, and many other major employers and healthcare facilities, this home offers both convenience and opportunity in one of Suffolk County's most desirable locations.

4 N Balin Court, South Setauket

$799,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 995561 MLS

Welcome to 10 Lily Drive, a unique opportunity set on over half an acre in the desirable South Setauket area. Tucked away with a deep setback and surrounded by mature trees, this property offers a setting with beautiful views. This spacious 2700 sq ft home features a well-designed layout with generous living areas, cathedral ceilings, and an abundance of natural light throughout. The primary suite offers elevated views of the surrounding landscape, including stunning sunsets, along with a private en-suite bath. Additional features include a 2-car garage and ample outdoor space with endless potential. This is not your average foreclosure—offering size, setting, and standout features that are hard to find. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, and major roadways. A rare opportunity to bring your vision to a property with exceptional upside.

10 Lily Drive, South Setauket

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.