Share this with your friends
+15166964653
Gold Coast Real Estate Group
Market report, updated
Shelter Island Home Values and Market Report
Search in the city of Shelter Island
/u.realgeeks.media/therealgoldcoastrealty/ee58d2fe-d536-4a97-aa9b-0f9f47844ffb-removebg-preview.png)
Market at a glance
Over the last 12 months, homes sold for 94.4% of list price in 199 days on average.
Average price, last 12 months
What sellers asked vs. what homes actually sold for, by closing month.
Homes sold per month
Closed sales, last 12 months.
Peak: 2 sales in Jan. Last month: 0.
Where the market stands
All homes in this report, by status.
Buyer's or seller's market?
Months it would take to sell every active home at the pace of the last 6 months.
Buyers have room to negotiate in this market.
Average price by status
Average days on market
Browse homes by status
Choose a status to see its numbers, charts and listings.
Active homes
Currently for salePrice vs. living area
Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.
4 homes didn’t report living area and aren’t shown.
How long homes have been listed
Number of homes by days on market.
Bedroom mix
Number of homes by bedroom count.
4 homes didn’t report bedrooms and aren’t shown.
Highest price per ft²
Top 7 homes in this status.
All active listings
Every home in this list is on the map. Click a marker for the home.
| Address | Beds | Baths | Living ft² | List price | $ / ft² | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 45 Lake Drive #BShelter Island, NY 11964 | — | — | — | $835,000 | — | 1 day |
| 2 Quail RunShelter Island, NY 11964 | 3 | 3 | 2,228 | $2,495,000 | $1,119 | 8 days |
| 27 Lakeview DriveShelter Island, NY 11964 | — | — | — | $749,000 | — | 30 days |
| 2 Pandion RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | — | — | — | $2,800,000 | — | 30 days |
| 20 Baldwin RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 3 | 3,097 | $3,250,000 | $1,049 | 30 days |
| 5 MarcShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 4 | 2,777 | $1,999,999 | $720 | 37 days |
| 7 Wheeler RoadShelter Island, NY 11965 | 4 | 3 | 2,289 | $2,690,000 | $1,175 | 58 days |
| 11 Jaspa RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 2 | 2 | 1,464 | $1,250,000 | $853 | 63 days |
| 9 Bay Shore DriveShelter Island, NY 11964 | — | — | — | $1,595,000 | — | 72 days |
| 169 N Ferry RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 6 | 3,500 | $4,250,000 | $1,214 | 95 days |
Under contract homes
Pending and contingent salesPrice vs. living area
Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.
2 homes didn’t report living area and aren’t shown.
Days on market before going under contract
Number of homes by days on market.
Bedroom mix
Number of homes by bedroom count.
2 homes didn’t report bedrooms and aren’t shown.
Highest price per ft²
Top 4 homes in this status.
All under contract listings
Every home in this list is on the map. Click a marker for the home.
| Address | Beds | Baths | Living ft² | List price | $ / ft² | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Brander ParkwayShelter Island, NY 11964 | 2 | 1 | 936 | $900,000 | $961 | 24 days |
| 61 N Cartwright RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 5 | 4 | 3,262 | $2,230,000 | $683 | 12 days |
| 14B Heron LaneShelter Island, NY 11964 | — | — | — | $3,750,000 | — | 26 days |
| 21 Tims TrailShelter Island, NY 11964 | — | — | — | $575,000 | — | 148 days |
| 11 Mimosa PlaceShelter Island, NY 11964 | 3 | 3 | 1,564 | $1,275,000 | $815 | 165 days |
| 12 Terry Dr.Shelter Island, NY 11964 | 5 | 5 | 4,200 | $2,800,000 | $666 | 208 days |
Sold homes
Closed in the last 12 monthsPrice vs. living area
Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.
How long homes took to sell
Number of homes by days on market.
Bedroom mix
Number of homes by bedroom count.
Highest price per ft²
Top 7 homes in this status.
Sold price vs. list price
How close homes sold to their asking price.
All sold listings
Every home in this list is on the map. Click a marker for the home.
| Address | Beds | Baths | Living ft² | Sold price | Sold / list | $ / ft² | Days to sell | Sold date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 S Menantic RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 4 | 1,702 | $1,460,000 | 100.7% | $857 | 305 days | Aug 27, 2026 |
| 73 N Midway RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 3 | 2,296 | $1,600,000 | 86.7% | $696 | 251 days | Aug 24, 2026 |
| 16 Shelterlands PathShelter Island, NY 11964 | 3 | 3 | 1,950 | $1,140,000 | 97.0% | $584 | 58 days | Jul 20, 2026 |
| 10 Strawberry LaneShelter Island, NY 11964 | 3 | 2 | 1,340 | $999,000 | 83.6% | $745 | 211 days | Jun 11, 2026 |
| 21 Thompson RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 2 | 2 | 1,504 | $5,700,000 | 97.0% | $3,789 | 116 days | Apr 7, 2026 |
| 1 Gazon RoadShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 3 | 2,618 | $1,180,000 | 94.4% | $450 | 160 days | Mar 26, 2026 |
| 156 Ram Island DriveShelter Island, NY 11964 | 4 | 4 | 3,420 | $2,679,000 | 97.4% | $783 | 449 days | Jan 21, 2026 |
| 27 Country Club DriveShelter Island, NY 11964 | 3 | 2 | 3,170 | $1,725,000 | 93.2% | $544 | 221 days | Jan 14, 2026 |
| 12 Terry DriveShelter Island, NY 11964 | 5 | 5 | 4,200 | $2,799,000 | 100.0% | $666 | 24 days | Nov 14, 2025 |
Questions about this market?
These numbers move every month. For what they mean for your home, or for a home you have your eye on, get in touch.
Next steps
Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.